Altamid Drones vs. Super Battle Droids

[Khas 12,158]

Alright, here's something I don't think we've done before.  Discuss the value of various war robots.

 

So, let's take a thousand of the Altamid Drones from Star Trek Beyond, and pit them against a thousand of the CIS' Super Battle Droids.

 

Scenario 1: A battle in an open plane.

 

Scenario 2: A battle set in a much more confined area.  In this case, brewery that was used for Star Trek XI's engine room scene.

 

How do these battles play out?

[Gunbird 519]

Like this for the both of them.

And this.

 

[IkaikaKekai 10,518]

Assuming it's just the robots and no one directly giving them orders/tactics and that they're using 'standard' weapons (just their arm cannons).  Think I'd give the open plane battle to the B2s, just a bunch of heavily armored and armed robots marching forward in unison and blasting away.  The close quarters battle I would give to the Altamid drones, they seem better suited to small squad/ambush tactics while the B2s are pretty much 'go forward, kill' if left on their own.