Jump to content
News Ticker
  • IPB version 4.2 installed!
  1. The Bridge

    1. Main Engineering

      Questions, suggestions, site information, and other such things.

      725
      posts
    2. Scifights.net, Geek's Basement, ASVS Commentaries Discussion Forum

      The official discussion forum for Brian Young's video commentaries and case studies on scifights.net, Geek's Basement Submissions and ASVS Commentaries.

      3,847
      posts
    3. The Mental Gymnasium

      The place where we bend over backward to reconcile inconsistencies and plot holes in sci-fi.

      277
      posts
    4. The Nexus

      Discussion of Sci-Fi, Fantasy, TV shows, video games, etc.

      4,805
      posts
    5. Versus Debates

      Star Trek Vs. Star Wars and debates of all other Sci-Fi universes!

      5,893
      posts
    6. Vulcan Science Academy

      Discussion of real-world science, mathematics and technology.

      350
      posts
    7. Shitposting

      Memes, shitposting, etc. Warning edgy content. If you are easily butthurt, do not enter.

      1,891
      posts
    8. The ASVS Grand Story Forum

      Discussions regarding the planned epic, collaborative Star Trek/Star Wars crossover story.  As well as discussing the story itself, once it gets underway.

      12
      posts
  2. Captain's Quarters

    1. Ten Forward

      Discussion of all forms of technology, computers, media, books, TV shows, movies, video games, etc.

      4,937
      posts
    2. The Neutral Zone

      Discuss, mock, whine, and complain about your favorite and least favorite boards. Shameless plugging and recruiting for other boards goes here as well. (Translation: The affairs of other boards DO concern us.)

      967
      posts
  3. ASVS Culture

    1. The Tomb of the Great Old Ones

      A place of remembrance for our fallen brethren.

      2
      posts
    2. 392
      posts
    3. 600
      posts
    4. Khas' Corner

      Where Khas reviews stuff and does Dramatic Readings of bad fanfics. He will also provide recipes from time to time.

      130
      posts
    5. The Art Gallery

      A place for folks to share their various artwork, should they feel like it.

      35
      posts
  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 4 Guests (See full list)

    There are no registered users currently online

  • Posts

    • This is part of the reason I made the suggestion.  If you ignore the TNG-era, the debate suddenly becomes a lot more interesting, because instead of Voyager taking decades to get home, or kt-Mt torpedoes, you're looking GO24, or the "Obsession" AM change putting a decent-sized hole in a planet or the E-nil treating a 1000-ly trip as an inconvenience in "That Which Survives".
    • That is quite tempting at times, I will admit.  However, having grown up with both TOS and TNG, it would be hard for me to throw THAT out. Right now, what I'm thinking is this: Trek Canon: Original Series, First four movies, Undiscovered Country, Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, Generations, and First Contact are definitely canon, with everything else being "pick-and-choose".  I.E., pick the worldbuilding elements such as events, characters, species, natural phenomena, and starship classes from the other series, movies, and video games that fit with the overall "feel", and disregard the rest. Wars Canon: Original Trilogy, Prequel Trilogy, The Clone Wars, Rebels, Rogue One, and Solo, along with the "Tarkin" and "Thrawn" novels.  Disregard the Sequel Trilogy, that was a floundering pile of pointlessness.   Obviously, starship weapons yields and the like will be "massaged", in order to prevent curbstomps.  Because stompfics like "Portal" and "Conquest" are, to be frank, at best boring, and usually just godawful.
    • How about just going back to basics? Wars Canon: Original Trilogy Trek Canon: Original series and first four films.
    • Alright, given the developments in both Trek and Wars since this post was made (2 years already?  Jesus...), this will have to be... updated.  Quite a bit.
    • Who cares about Jimmy? I want to fuck Jimmy's mom.  
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      5,541
    • Most Online
      853

    Newest Member
    L' oktar
    Joined
×