Jason

You weren't clear before. We can speculate that there was a feedback\splashback resulting in shield damage or that power was being shunted from shields to the deflector so the longer they fired the deflector dish the more energy being drained away from the shields?

I take the feedback damage to the shields as much more likley. Because they talked about shield damamge.

Make more senses one want to think Fact USS Enterprise D could withstand level a little above 12,000 means C and Fact Date said fire photon torpedo so close would with out shield could destroy USS Enterprise D I think even strong evidence back claim your clain even more so.

USS Defiant is more maneuverable then a Y-wing and fasters. USS Defiant like all Federation starships has some from technology makes weapons often miss by tricking the sensors. Other wise you have a lot explaining to do why Star Terk Gernations that Bird Pray miss so many times. So no reason to think big guns around Dearth star will do much better so even with out the cloak devices. One man tie fighters will be harmless to USS Defiant. As for far hole goes most likely land shuttle right near it and few Federation crews carries piece photon torpedo and put together lit drop.

Wasn't the frequency modulated? If so then the Borg wasn't able to adapt to it in time. If the E-D just kept firing then they would have knocked out their shields, I think.

I am talk about USS Entperise D shields forward shields down to 58% that weapon no effect on the borg cube.

I think first Death star monster worthly USS Defiant.

How come after the USS Enterprise D used main defector dish as a weapon against the Borg cube shields down to about 58%

USS Defiant can fire phasers and photon torpodoes in the backwards beyound there is very a lot more maneuverable then Y wing. To make matter worst Y wing Squadron the USS Defoamt has senser jaming systoms seem cause great amount problems to the Jem'Hadar attack ships. A Nebula Class starship can hit smell shuttlecaft I think a Defient class starship would have easy time knock out a Y wing Squadron.

Y wing poor maneuverable and it is very low compare to other one man fighters. USS Defiant is fast and very maneuverable. So one on One a Y wing not have fight chance. However Y wing Squadron of about 12 fighters be not be a fair fight. USS Defiant could keep distance destroy fighters one by one. Because Defiant class starships faster and more maneuverable than a Y wing. Only way Y wing squadron have chance is if sensors a defiant class starship are off line . One Y wing iron cannon would not have the strength to disable a Defiant class starship. It just to smell however 6 Y wings going fire iron cannons might have strength 12 Y wings fire iron cannon would most likely have the strength. Then could stable Defiant class starship in the back.

If take away the force Kahless would kill Darth Vader.

Okay, I need you to be a bit more clear on what you are trying to say. Are you trying to say that the damaging of the shields was due to splash damage from firing the amped up phaser blast? IIRC the shields were only at 58% because of the initial encounter with the Borg, in that episode, when the Borg completely shut down the shields. Giordi was just getting them back up, IIRC.

I am trying to say that the damaging of the shields was due to splash damage from firing the amped up Main defector dish blast

I was saying damage from blast of main defector dish. That causes the forward shield to get down to 58%. That what I am thinking happen with the information I have.

Right, and since the navigational deflector is most likely a related system to the shields, and we know that they are both related to the main reactor, the damage could have fed back from the deflector system, through the reactor, and to the shield system. One place we know Federation technology is deficient is in circuit breakers.

I could buy aruement if was not for the fact USS Enterpise D SAUCER SECTION has to have own shields. Forward shields down 58 percent does.

The were shield damage on USS Entprise D.

Yeah, and on some things that's good advice, but you're just going to get beaten on here with that attitude towards the physics based issues. I'd stick to literary criticism until you get a better grasp of physics. Physics isn't that hard as long as you can do the math.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

So the blast overloaded the main deflector, and fed back in to to related systems? How does this in any way imply that the energy hitting the borg cube did that damage?

 

 

 

Sounds to me like they fused some circuit breakers.

 

 

 

Seriously, how old are you? You don't seem to be thinking through any of your positions logically. You just presented evidence that refutes one of your original premises, i.e. that the Enterprise deflector could channel that much energy. Obviously it couldn't.

I am 25 years of age however I am disable

Yoda is a better fighter and at using the forces. Spock is better at science and reading people minds. As for known fixes things it depends the item.

 

Obviously.

 

 

 

Having not taken any physics, what makes you think you have any ability to argue in a physics based vs. thread?

 

 

 

I alway was hard hiter in try find answer.If someone said it can not be done try do no matter what odds.

 

By be words Commander Riker . anticipated, the

 

blast burned out the main

 

navigational deflector... we also have damage to shields and the reactor core.

I have not take any phyical.

USS Entprise D sheilds were damage as it was so Commander Riker was choese a distance the USS Entprise D shield could withstand.

I was saying from 30,000km was suidice for USS Enterpise not 40,000. If heat will not do it what else could USS Enterpise D destory it.

Hull of a Galaxy class starship can withstand a little more then twelve-thousand degrees C according to Star terk (TNG: "Descent, Part II") According to Star terk best both Worlds. IF the USS Enterpise D fire closer then 40,000 km the USS Enterpise D would destory by the blast. Because did how close USS Enterpise have to be to got damge. So known you do the math find out for yourself.

Here how I did it

read

Check out nuclear bomb blast it lose about half it every 2 miles. 30,000 kms is about 18,645 miles. Times it by two then times it by 720,000 and you got 4,428,000 degree Celsius the real amount heat the USS Enterprise D hit that burg cube with.. If accurse 30,000 km is suicide with the USS Enterprise D using her main defector dish as a weapon with her shields up. I do not think a star destroyer it could withstand that kind of heat.

If say I am wrong did the math yourself and show me.

I am not suggesting that at all about the main defector dish. What I am suggesting when main defector dish beam hits it target that the amount heat 4,428,000 degree Celsius it give off. Fact when using the main defector dish as a weapon they need to evacuate the entire forward half of the secondary hull and the lower three decks of the saucer because radicals danger. The energy levels have to give few seconds to build up before it can be fire .A galaxy class starship defector dish may well be able to take many times heat levels of Galaxy class starship hull.

It is also possible that and Cardassians and Romulans Star ships were using tricobalt devices instead Photon torpedoes in this design more planet attack. I also already said Galaxy class starship defector dish more power weapon anything Star Destroyer can give off.

Well, there's no reason we can't continue it here. Cut and paste if you must.

Thier are some differnt people on this site that are not part Jedi Starfleet. I hope also got hear some thier views as will.

Only things I known about this spacecrafts is it does not have a warp drive and UFP only send three spacecraft try stop a Borg cube when had more available.

By saying had to do Politics are you sugesting that UFP was not fighting a war of surival against Klingon during Star Terk Yesterday Enterprise. Over something terriory issues that Federation afford to give up.