Jason

You want another answer I gave you one does go against all other cannon for why Pircard statement might no choice surrender.

At least Republic army used equipment commando much more advance sense equipment. No means average Clone trooper or Stromtrooper senser like that available.

Vader crash land on the planet Minos on own personal tie fighter. Echo Papa 607 drone is after him. Vader a died man and goner that probe fire weapons it can take heavy beaten to.

To be honest different way of explain why Federation force to surrender which not having go against every other piece of cannon date in we know Klingon Empire and size United Federation of Planets. The Dominion leader stated order conquest prize the size Federation need vast number starships and men and equmeent even big for Dominion standers. if the Dominion find it near hard to do ship much faster Klingon warship then then the Klingon Empire impossible surrender would mean giving up mass amount Territory maybe even key worlds nothing compare surrender to Borg. Federation even Yesterday Enterprise timeline unlikely strength to fight both the Borg and Klingon Empire. This explain Guinan so desperation end Yesterday Enterprise timeline.

In Old Republic I think must people have good education. In Galactic Empire discrimation against all none humans they anyone not human not have good education.

Let face Death star planet destroy weapon ton weakness. It lack powerful effective shielding and even blow me up port vent lack shield prevent solid and weapons flying thougt. It very possible Death star shield only design protect against energy base weapons so planety destroy weapon lot more ask of. But as space artillery it long range hit target far away and star destroy and fighter simple provide protecting it deliver heavly blow enemy fleet.

Let face while at least book one best ground combat force when coming space fleets they are weak. Fact Come space force they terrible weak. There space force does not provide fire support ground troopers. We never get to seem them having space to space combat most likley about good aim star destroyer. Since never see starship real hit target that one look window to see.

Let face Vader and Star Terk Voyager Kes the last time we saw them interest fight to death. They more or less evenal match Vader has force us control enemy partice. Kes pure power alone Vader no match with mind tricks he may stand a chance. Who win fight to the death.

It real depend it is done more issue anything else it could best of all Star Terk leave Wrath Khan in the dust or it could worst movie made. Star Terk first contact could been best Star Trek movie ever for all reason should been but was not. If they instead start out Guinan homeworld being destroy Borg show people fleet destory quick out effect in first rathering show unless talk then hear Guinan question if UFP realistic stop Borg now sending fleet ships. Then show Pircard using knowledge Borg single handle slow prevent fleet one ship time travel better part move show Borg terror then showing Borg when Pircard notice it cut out much fighting ship even maybe space combat part even though cool. So I agree it could great Star Terk movie it also terrible Star Trek who could believe could do bad Borg. Translation: It really depends on how it is done, more than anything else. I think it could be the best Star Trek movie of all time, save for the Wrath of Khan. It would leave the rest of them in the dust; or it could be the worst movie of the bunch. The content of First Contact was such that it could have been the best one, but the execution was poor. If they instead started out by showing the destruction of Guinan's home world at the hands of the Borg, then cut to the Borg destroying the Federation's fleet, while Guinan questions whether or not they could be defeated, then showed Picard using his knowledge of the Borg to slow the borg down enough with a single ship to prevent the destruction of the fleet. I agree it could be a great movie, but I am worried about their execution of the idea.

Let face even TNG equipment in Lesson set up able allow Federation soldiers fire Jem Harder well making the Jem Harder fire back harmless. So why so poorly equipment starfleet give basic military equement that had availabe and people train to us it.

Intercept class starship going at 80% speed of light and using EW warfare would rammed the Death star would likley do the trick of destory it. Of course crew leave the starship with the help escape podes ship set auto pilot . After all Death star shacked great deal when X wing rammed Vader shoot down. That thing going no were near 80% speed of light. Intercept class starship likley Death star destroy it out right. Even Death star not destroy the crew on the Death star killed simple no way survival that kind impact.

The amount for fire power enough blow that Death star up many times over.

While Federation never approve compare this plan. They much better options available ust Include follow Send Defiant class starship using main defector dish or send or Promethium class to us it main defector dish to blow the Death star sky high. Or for what ever reason Federation need to turn Intercept class starship into missles take out something like the Death star. Intercept starship as it is able carry as it is 150 photon torpedoes hardly packed. Means Intercept class starship likely fit a at least 150,000 possible even 150 millions to upper limits of course way more then enough of a blast to destroy the Death star since only the size of smell moon. Federation might even already have missiles handle the Death star

We no evidence even suggestion that Death Star has that kind shield at least cannon evidence. For that matter evidence that it does not likley because power issues. One that star destroyer crash into the Death star as far I can tell it did leave a dent. If wish see evidence watch this video form 6 minute and 22 seconds to about 6 minute 50 seconds. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZDa09gRDq8 That Star Destroyer crash it explode on impact suggestion effect Death star had some kind of shields still up even though the main shield generation that moon Ender was down .Suggestion Death star shield design stop object about size star destroyer not design stop something size Millennium Falcon. Intercept class starship might even be the same size as the Millennium Falcon. Suggesting Death star simple not have the power need to type shield you required. Only with Endor protect Death star with another shield generation was Death star were one man fighter and two man fighter and ship the size of Millennium Falcon unable fly right though it. Must the Death star shield making minor delay maybe few seconds more the Death star crew having time to responsed.

We seen UFP us EW warfare all the time fact starship often so miss targets. Smell piece dust going 80% speed light if hit something give more energy then the must power nuclear bomb ever build. However Intercept class starship weights about 70,000 tons that hititng Death star not going light at all. Toproode miss the Death star made the Death star shack a Intercept class starship rammed it 80% speed lighting going real make it shack. Guessing it does not destroy Death star out right if the Intercept class starship rammed way into main reactor core the Death star would go bang.

I found few more problems with you tantic. Let say for secound Intercept class starship could pull big piece space rock. Still left question any Sane Caption did it ok Janeway just might crazy enough try it. Left fact reason Intercept class starship is design survival high speeds it two two defector dish design push out way space rockes. It has warp nacelle are program to bend. Second enemy decide to rammed USS Voyager she going place lot stuff flooting around. Defector dish likley clear area of space allow such fast speed.

Simple way over come problem wieght is to us warp bubble that of course asteroid lot lighter. They made DS9 much lighter with us warp bubble. So might allow USS Voyager did the trick. If USS Voyager could pull DS9 it warp bubble around it is unknown. They even made planetet lighter by the way warp bubble. Of course plan must change the UFP pratice making object size astriond take same amount beaten but much lighter after all even NASA could build stuff lot tough and lighter then astriond had be about the same size to.

Also forgive the MI might well have a device that can pick Predators I saw on Starship troopers two. It might able get past the Predator cloak device and might not.

Predator starship crash land full face hunger in village on Federation colonies. One unlikley movie Aliens vrs Preadtor II. Federation know ship crash and normal starship troop investigate likley do much better other then able handle Aliens since they gun kill one shoot a piece. Predator starship arrive better keep cloak on because these human guns kill single hit. Mobile Infantry Troopers weapons easily handle aliens.

How in world would MI try lore them out into open? It kind like Xenos at least I understand everything they want in that town area. It not like shoot run after you or kill they charging after you. As fair I can tell it hard if not impossible did that. They simple nothing to lore out into open. As for them getting ground up,bit by bit. Problem is that Xenos normal did not kill prey right away bring into area facehuger fate mistake deal with MI. Predator allies with MI in case were Xenos are out control that tough one. Second Alien vs Predator movie the predator did turn the human for help in try stop the Xenos out break. In some case Predator used human as bait for Xenos help his hunt. On other hand how much help the Human been for that Predator is questionable. Major factor you seem forget Predator having code honor coming hunting. Every movie Predator easily could pick the soldiers very quickly in all Predator movies and Alien vrs Predator movies. Or even try attack head on. Predators instead seem choose not do so. The Predator aim not just kill MI but kill with style like try sneak behind them cut head or try sneak laser beam shot plamas cannon. Predator also done with risk themselves getting kill process like the Xenos. Fighting a Xenos one on one hardly safe thing for Predator to do when they have other weapon available. Armor would make different in that kind case were MI soldier might well notice that see shape Predator would give target for his rifle or his weapon stock in MI armor another MI clear shoot clear Predator. As for you suggestion Predators let two soften each other seem against code they just easily in second Alien vs Predator movie notice the US military let them deal problem alone or at least team. Fact in both movie Alien vs Predator the Predators made their business contain the Xenos means going fight town no matter what. They just going watch two side soften each up against Predator culture and possible laws. As for Predators teaming with MI is think happen one way or other at least first for simple reason. Predators know hunt MI gloriously high possible that they unable stop the Xenos. Stop the Xenos be major objective above hunt MI. MI hand grenades and bullet and can easily fetal wound a Predator. Possible that it well happen extremely simple after honor while hunting.

50 MI,3 Predators and 400 Xenos. Vrs of MI movie. I could easily see mass slaughter. Predator normal hunt groups 3. In the town it self another 200 citzens and 600 civilians. MI basic going fighting both Predator and Xenos in both open areas and inter areas of cities and area little both in them. 10 location show off school children. 10 Are location eating launch in restaurant. 20 MI in doing recruiting station hoping get more people join Federation military. 10 are in the park area. Well going to be slaughter say the least all sites worst off going adult citizens and civilians. In school easily seem them turn to tactic of going stay on roof and shoot any Xenos get that near them and turn one stair ways up chock point. I am not sure Predator code ethic work in this case. One hand the Predator did not kill children but would kill people protect children now out them they died we never seen case was this problem is relevant. Supermarket likley flee basement area and one way in or out as choke point any enter that not human dies. Once park basic shoot any move kill Predators. 20 people recruit station going bunkers try hold fort they likely survival since Predator and Xenos hard time go pass codes. MI have armor that least delay bug bit them in half. So it likley provide protect against KE weapons that Predator is armed with. As for

I agree you that Empire have rest fleet to try fight Federation but they weaken by intelligence information Federation get . Genetic engineer boi weapon lot hard stop even try kill boi weapon much harder kill natural germs Mean us real methid stop the spread.As for defense 20 runabouts easily break though first Death star defense. Once must them get past the defesne just beam in boi weapon. Death star crew response biological attack shock and aw. Fact must upper decks in number hours likely all have put quarantine. Then of course beam boarding parties aboard help transporter enhance. to open the hanger bring troops and shuttlecaft they beam in even deeper it not long before must Death star is under Quarantine. Also possible all out surrender after board hanger bay. Also mission easily allow section 31 steal longer number GE combat space Vehicle. Include possible Star destroyer that might well stored in the Death star. This would strongth UFP able to wage a war against the Star War GE. By know must if not all Star destroyer secrets. Know hit the enemy starship practice terms can allow single starship perhaps take on 2 or 3 ISD at a time would greatly weaken Empire. Again intelligence place big part in the must wars.

Very simple beam biological attack and watch rest Empire crew died from disease quickly maybe hours then take Death star for themselves.

I not be so sure about that one because science fiction villion afford have 2 kiloton nuclear grenades throw right at live tell tail about some science fiction need kill special way. Fact they even need ground force that effective put entire space force into question must at least star terk weapons hear or just get seem used once so know to little Star Terk ground force able make any thing but guess work able.

Federation in Movie Starship troops pick lost contact one colony send starship to check out investigate the same mission from movie Alien. Fact is one militery starship carry lot bigger crew then the USMC starship send in so could see Alien get crush simple numbers.