Jason

I think place you read it was here My link While cannon site per say it is pro trek site battle star trek verse star wars

Simple put way Star Destroyer shield seem to stop sold objects by vaporizing them.Problem with that method when come UFP photon torpedoes is they did not vaporize easily fact they can enter star core. If wish to see my evidence watch this video form 2 minute and 59 seconds to about 3 minute and 32 seconds. Liston part Chief engineer said that they have enter star core. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=81HJWE6wDow&feature=related

We seen Starship destroy sold KE weapons before with phasers. Watch this video form 2 minute 13 seconds to about to 2 minute and 14 seconds. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1BLDCQvaT0M However never seen anyone even try to shot down photon torpedo

More evidence idea photon torpedoes some kind shielding is fact we never seen anyone try knock photon torpedoes with phasers or some other kind energy weapons it like need shields to stop them.

Star War Empire attack Dominion hoping get Dominion cloning technology. Even thought Jem Harder battleship smaller and more powerful then Star Destroyer. Dominion many more bug ships then Dominion battleships and likely be those jem harder attack bug ships be once stopping star destroyer crashing into to them. After all that Asteroids crash into star destroyer some damage what do think Jem Harder attack ship crashing Star destroyer would do. It most likely alot harder for star destroyer shield to stop Asteroid.

Main different between these torpedoes and normal one guild systems if wish see evidence watch this video form 3minute and 3 seconds to about 3 minute and 43 seconds to about. Liston part Date making comment guild systems. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_s9frpIl6M&feature=related

If starfleet Admiral say that they enough personal force field to entire army. Back up seen Worf make personal force field communicator fact starfleet use very often more to do fact they only work for at must hour.

Wait minute is another example of personal force field used it not for combat use thought. If wish see evidence watch video form 4 minute and 11 seconds to about 5 minute and 30 seconds http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pjtNAO5VQqo&feature=related Liston to them talk about subspace force field.

Why claiming about idea Enigma should every science fiction debate board have one of me. What Science fiction debate board with out Jason.

Hay one think to try insult me another thing to insult everyone that is retarded. Wait minute found another reason we not did normal see UFP personal using force field be used in combat. Worf personal force field and strength enough stop holographic bullets only work for few seconds. So someone carry something like 1,100 communicators size Worf wearing for it work one hour. This back even more so by fact Borg walk about same speed as a human but are much stronger any body in UFP other Data. So likely personal force field weight a lot as will. That be good reason why we did not see UFP security personal wearing them. Must time starship security fight criminals or intruder often run extremely fast. Normal not charge station near by UFP security personal in fire fight. So personal force field might will useful try defend territory over runned.

If guy see way I think that is personal force field watch first video form 1 minute and 10 seconds to about 1 minute and 14 seconds. See light flash around Worf he get hit bullets. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jI9SHDoW4-o Now if watch this video and see Seska walk force field 7 minute and 19 seconds to about 7 minute and 25 seconds. See how light up when she walk force field and still on when get though force field.See two them near to identical.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xp7fY0G11sM

We never seen used combat however during Voyager did see engineer personal using personal force field.

To make simple personal force field one many type combat equipment never get see UFP personal but talking used off screen. photon granade best example of that. Simple put he heard first TNG basic heard at least few time DS9 and we heard sound effect in Voy.

A stromtrooper hit R2-D2 very effective during Star War return of Jedi. It like plot say Stromtrooper has good aim he has good aim. When Star Terk plot say UFP personal has personal force field he has personal force field.

In practice it TV show that simple answer comes Starfleet personal while on screen did not have personal force field on other when happen fit plot. Same argument could use for Star Wars. Hear Ben once saying only stromtroops have that kind aim. With all due respect the sand people when on screen have much better aim then stromtrooper on screen.

Here example personal force field See weapon not even touching her and still push back by it.

I could think few reasons why we never get see it be used in combat First possible only used for ground combat. Maybe artificial gravity make personal force field useless when come stopping phaser beams or other energy base weapons. Hay Worf commutator fail to stop bullet in anycase Second possible is advancement weapons against advancement of personal force fields. UFP maybe used personal force field during some fire fights. Then Dominion upgrade hand weapons to either just over power personal force fields. UFP had then to work on geting personal force field that provide protect against Dominion hand weapons. Then the Dominion was able over come those personal force fields. All ground battles we get to see were UFP enemy have upper hand. Third possible fact they take special training UFP might will have the able to give every person ever born UFP person force field. But it could danger to user if he or she does not us it right.

UFP still wear armor if wish to see evidence UFp combat uniform provide watch these videos First video it show someone wearing normal UFP uniform as you can see green flash after he get hit. 4 minute and 14 seconds to about and 16 seconds. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4fp2VJ9nqc&feature=related See green flash goes off after the poor person normal uniform after sparks flying and then green flash. Now watch this video show UFP soldier combat uniform on 4 minute and 45 seconds to about 5 minute and 54 seconds http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5bJHOjR48BY&feature=related As you guys can see UFP soldier when they get hit Klingon disruptor no green flash happen after sparks. When UFP person wearing normal uniform Klingon disruptor hits see green flash after sparks. My theory UFP combat uniform at least prevent UFP person vaporized and most likely lighten the blow. For example much higher kill setting would likely needed to kill them. Other wise I like some please explain why a green flash after spark UFP personal in a normal starfleet uniform get hit but no green flash after sparks when someone is wearing UFP soldier uniform get hit.

Another possible personal force field only UFP Special Forces us them perhaps out required training need in order for them to use effectively in combat. Also UFP soldier uniforms might will provide some protect energy basic weapons.

Beyond simple fact biological weapon used Klingon Empire and it is likely Klingon had least few shipyard UFP territory during war. UFP us some those shipyard they captured to help rebuild fleet. First the Galaxy class starship yesterday Enterpise time-line did miss there targets unlikely UFP normal tine-line. In this vidoe show one time USS enterprise D in Yesterday Enterprise time-line defend USS Enterprise C form three BOP miss it target. Show once that USS Enterprise D weapon did not hit their targets. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNH300OmcKU What ever Galaxy class starship send likely turn the three Jem Harder starship that face space dust and rescue Sisko any problems. As for war the Dominion would have get past DS9 likley upgrade with same weapon system that all starbase in Yesterday Enterprise time-line likely both longer rang and be much more powerful. It possible DS9 with phaser and photon torpedoes denied Dominion able to enter Alpha and Beta Quarderon. To make matter Our solar system at least normal star Terk time-line over 14 ship yards that easily build 100 or more starship in four years.

I think new once the older class starship often easily to destroy in DS9 Take few hints.

My option on the issues first is the fact SW Empire happen bigger then either side during Clone wars. It simple fact Empire combine resources of Confederacy and Republic. So what might bankrupted the Republic would not have bankrupt Empire per say. Second both sides take heavy lose during war. Longer number warship, military equipment and soldier lost on both sides in practice war Attrition who ever fall first lose. Third fact anti-slavery law not been effect build Death star and cheaper us slave labor some out law in Republic.

Both these starfleet combat uniforms look took a beaten. In practice during battle at The Siege of AR-558" we did not see any new UFP soldier that combat uniforms get killed by Dominion polaron rifles.Every soldier that died form that weapon down wear stander starfleet uniforms.

More evidence that Uniforms the UFP soldiers wear is armor When UFP soldier stab in the back. I saw no one drop of blood come out of his back. If wish see evidence watch this video form 1 minute 27 seconds to one minute and 32 seconds. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZ61zkCAAbk If even question armor stop weapon get deep into body. He could just knock bow smell impact broken back.

If shuttlecaft land on top of it that near to impossible.