GhanjRho

Let me get this straight. you find Jason to be less annoying than enigma?

True, it probably would count as T-canon now. Half of this is old pent-up rage at people calling the EU non-canon. And after learning that the Empire has a weapon that can one-shot a planet, you don't the Rebellion would turn all their intel resources to trying to find it's blueprints? Remember that the Rebels had very good contacts within the Bothan spynet, which was the best in the galsxy (with the possible exception of the Black Sun spynet)

the official Lucasfilm canon policy states that all EU materials are C-canon, which places them below G-canon (Episodes I-VI + Direct statements from GL himself) and T-canon (Episode 2.fail, sorry, the Clone Wars and the Clone Wars animated series(es)) There is, in the GI article that first talked about TFU "The game's events are considered an official part of the Star Wars canon, an honor that hasn't been bestowed upon previous original Star Wars games."

I refer you to "The Force Unleashed", which has been declared to be G-Canon. which is the same tier as the movies. The EU exists, deal with it. http://www.subspace-comms.net/index.php?topic=2689.0;wap2

The Alliance first learned of the Death Star's existence through the Force, after Vader took the rebel leadership there. Following that, it seems only logical that they would devote any and all intelligence resources (of which they had quite a few, the Rebellion included parts of the Bothan spynet) to finding the plans for it, in the hopes of finding a way to neutralize it.

To Jason. The Maquis were born out of displaced colonists. their recruiting process was incredibly open. What checks they did have were to prevent spoonhead infiltration, not Fed. The Rebellion was born out of ex-Clone Wars military units, such as the Kota Militia, which were then unified with political dissident groups by Darth Vader. In other words, the Rebellion was built from groups that understood counter-intelligence. While they may have had someone on the secret base, there is no indication that they would have been able to get a signal out to the Empire at large. And even if they did, guess what happens? the Rebels pack up and move their base, conducting a through security sweep through their own ranks.

Let's be fair here. The Alpha Quadrant is smaller than the Empire, which covers a very large portion of it's galaxy. Finding a hidden base in the area the Empire has to search is akin to searching for a particular rock in the Federation. And not a distinctive rock, either.

I'm not saying its a rule. I'm just saying that many people pick a name that is either unrelated ( Mr. Oragahn, ricrey1, the 80 billion names of RSA) or solidly in one camp or the other (picard, Darth Wong, Kor, etc.). the KirkSkywalkers just happened to be relatively heavily biased.

Am I the only one who's noticed that a lot of the more biased individuals have names that include both franchises? You have Jedi Master Spock (and most of Starfleet Jedi), StarWarsStarTrek, KirkSkywalker, etc.

Then Poe decides he doesn't need to take my credit when I'm traveling with a Satanist. And seeing as we have no money, that leaves us with a ship that blows up halfway to Tethys.

Honestly, the thing that bugs me the most is that fact that she can't admit that she was wrong. when told her number was incredibly lowball, she tried to call on her military credentials. which were service as a deck crewman and then a media specialist.

"It's these Omegus-blighted engines. That power surge cut them off at the wrong time. We're fine now. Now both of you, listen. Ratboy, don't talk too much. Pitboy, don't talk at all. Got it?"

You have the Talifan chronology wrong. First, Karen Travissty came up with a bullshit lowball number for the number of clones in the GAR. then, some fans brought up the how stupid it was for an army of 3 million clones to be the entire army of ~million world polity. Said fans also took issue with the Sword of the Jedi needing to be trained in Jedi killing by a man not known for killing Jedi. Travissty then declared them to be the Talifan, while her loyal supporters were the "fandalorians". She is also on record threatening to rip out the trachea of one of her critics. I don't know if anyone threatened her with death, but I don't disbelieve it. How many of them were serious is another matter entirely.

My personal feeling is that in both entity-on-entity and ship to ship combat, Imperial win. this is absolutely nothing against Trek, just a commentary on the fact that they operate on entirely different levels, as they are stores with very different basises. Wars is the heroic epic, telling the story of people at the wrong place at the wrong time (naturally, they became heroes), fighting against the enemy they have no hope in hell of beating. and yet they do. Trek is the more cerebral, telling the story of man finding his way through a galaxy both new and strange. Also, (mildly unrelated) maybe I'm biased, but Trek seems to attract more crazies than Wars. Trek has RSA, who tried to tell Leland Chee that Chee was wrong about SW canon. Wars has Mike Wong, the certified mechanical engineer with the Imperial Smackdown. Not to mention, Trek has Jason. And I think I will should be fun

Who votes we send him to SpaceBattles? Or even better, SDN.